The days when Humeans and Homoousians mostly stayed out of one another's hair are gone, it seems, forever. |
Humeans could respond to this result by either giving up Centring or abandoning the idea that the most fundamental facts do not supervene on less fundamental facts. |
Humeans about motivation hold that desire is necessary for motivation, while Humeans about reasons hold that our reasons for action are grounded in our desires. |
Humeans about normative reasons claim that there is a reason for you to perform a given action if and only if this would promote the satisfaction of one of your desires. |
The underlying goal is to test whether causality is extrinsic for Humeans and intrinsic for anti-Humeans in this sense. |
In layman's terms, Piper stands Humeans and Kantians back-to-back, pointing to the disingenuousness of the former and the laziness of the latter. |